How to break up with your Church

The moment when you feel, “its not YOU, it’s ME,” with your church, when there are no bad feelings and nothing happened but it’s just time to move on.

Since I started working full time Monday- Friday and the boys have been in pre-school, I have felt like I haven’t got to spend enough time with them, this coupled with the fact that Ben works every Saturday until almost 5 and it seems like we never get any family time any more. It’s been hard. Every day we are rushing somewhere and  since work isn’t optional, the day that got all the stress fell to Sunday. We were cranky, exhausted and our smiles were stretched thin as we tried to cram in what is most important.

The last few months of Sundays since we switched churches to attend a Saturday night service have been full of sleeping-in, fun and relaxing at home with the family. These mornings have been some of the best days I’ve had this year.  A local church that I attended in high school has a Saturday night service that has fit perfectly into our new lives and we have been attending lately, which feels all sorts of weird but still very right.

I have loved my church home for the last 8 years but life has changed and now I’m changing to keep up. My heart will always be with my old church, and maybe when life gets less crazy we can go again. I just know for now we can’t.

So, for fun, here are my top 3 ways how [*cough cough* …. not] to break up with a church:

1.  Don’t say anything. If you see someone you know from your old church go with, “Oh, we switched services!” Keep tithing and when friends or staff members persist in asking where you have been adamantly insist that you have been faithfully serving in the nursery or the youth. Changing the answer back and forth will trick them for quite some time.

2. Make a very public exit- ‘reply all’ to a message from the staff or think of everyone you know in the church and announce your departure in a bulk email. Give them in detail every reason you have for leaving and tell them all the things you have held in over the years. Treat it like an exit interview.  

3. Stop tithing. They’ll get the picture.

**********

Or just do nothing other than tell a few close friends.  Unless you are a part of a cult, more than likely everyone you know will be happy that you are doing good and excited that you have found a place that meets your current needs. I am a people pleaser as well as a chronic-over-sharer and it’s hard for me to move on from a place that has meant so much to me in the past without telling everyone I know all the reasons so there are no hurt feelings- and yes I see the irony here in me bloging about it. 😉 Does it feel like I’m leaving a family? Very much so, I feel a bit insecure and wonder at times if our decision is right but the peace and joy that have returned to our lives is all the answer I need. 

  • http://www.adollopofmylife.com/ lindseylu

    I’m glad you’ve found something that fits your family best. We have A LOT of friends at Saturday night (did you know Alaina is there now?), but for now, it makes my boys crank pots to be up past their bedtime or their eating time. I think eventually we’ll probably switch over b/c we love Chip and Mark!

  • Julie Fish

    You know what? The “body of Christ” isn’t just one congregation or just one church group. I think you are going to a time of worship that fits your lifestyle.
    Selfishly, will I miss those hugs from Bear, grins from Sawyer, “catch up” with my friend Heidi & watching Ben’s face of pride at his family? Dearly!
    Am I glad things are working out for you? Totally! Love you, Julie :><

  • Nancy Davidson

    I feel your pain! When we made the move to a Church much closer to us….10 minutes from getting in the car to the doorstep!….I felt so torn on how to tell everyone at New Heights. I felt like putting up a huge banner, saying, “We’re not upset about anything, we still love everyone & we are going too miss each of you, but we feel this is best for us.” Nancy

  • Stef

    I’m so glad Mosaic is working out well for y’all! Getting to have Sundays as a fam was one of the main reasons we started going, as well. I switch between 1st & 2nd service, depending on whether or not Josh has to work 2nd service, but I’ll keep an eye out for you anytime I’m there for the 1st!

  • TheBusyNothings

    We are excited to be there. It still feels like a small church- and it’s actually smaller than New Heights was which is kind of funny b/c originally Fellowship was a little too big for Ben’s preferences. :)

  • TheBusyNothings

    YEP. 100% agreed!

  • TheBusyNothings

    I’m going to miss you too!!!!! Hopefully we can still have lunch sometimes! I gotta have my Julie fix! :)

  • TheBusyNothings

    it’s been amazing so far!

  • http://www.facebook.com/sarea.clark Sarea Clark

    This one has been heavy on my heart for a little over a month now….I’ve been avoiding the ‘break up’…thanks for the permission, and the ‘how to’…LOL I will keep you posted! XOXO

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=20620796 Katy Nelson Schmidt

    This totally reminds me of a quote from Francis Chan’s “Crazy Love” about lukewarm Christians. “Lukewarm Christians attend church fairly regularly. It is what is expected of them, what they believe ‘good Christians’ do, so they go.” Great article Heidi!!!